What Personalities Are You Looking For?

by | Apr 5, 2023 | Hiring Tips | 0 comments

By: Kellie Lail

Before you can begin to decide what personality types you are looking for, you must know exactly what role you need to fill in your agency. Every agency has a little bit different idea of what responsibilities fall under a certain job title, so make sure you have a clear idea of what responsibilities the role you need to fill will entail. Ensure that you are writing a job ad to clearly describe those responsibilities.

For a solid foundation of success, you should also understand what personalities you currently have in your office. This will help you to understand what personality traits your top performers in various roles have so you can try to replicate those numbers or fill in the gaps with your new hires.

Keep in mind, everyone’s Performance Index numbers can vary. It is important to fully review each personality result to understand how the numbers can help someone in a certain role and where you may need to provide extra support or training based on their job duties.

*Personalities are listed in alphabetical order for ease of reference.


Examples of Potential Responsibilities: Relationship building, follow-ups, obtaining referrals, networking with existing/previous customers, warm leads/leads provided, cross-selling/account rounding, taking payments, updating client information, issuing insurance documentation, policy changes, shopping renewals, scheduling appointments, maintaining client retention, educate & advise clients on policies.

Personalities Suited for these Responsibilities: Closer, Competitor (with High Motivation – 60 and above), Engineer*, Independent, Knowledgeable, Networker**, Persistent**, Planner**, Sales Leader, Sales Person

Potential Roles: Inside Sales Representative, Outside Sales Representative, Account Executive, Sales Manager, Business Development Representative, Life Insurance Sales, Telemarketing***.

  • ** – These personalities may need additional training or supervision to be more successful with cold-calling.
  • *** – Telemarketing should be a stepping stone into a sales position.

Customer Service

Examples of Potential Responsibilities: Educate & advise clients on policies, objection handling/win backs, cold-calling/telephone prospecting, develop insurance quotes, make sales presentations, relationship building, networking/developing leads, cross-selling/account rounding, policy changes, shopping renewals.

Personalities Suited for these Responsibilities: Competitor (with Low Motivation – 40 and below), Competitor (with High Motivation – 60 and above), Consistent, Knowledgeable, Nurturer, Organizer, Perfectionist, Researcher

Potential Roles: Account Manager, Customer Service and Sales Representative, Customer Service Representative, Customer Success, Customer Support, Client Success Manager, Retention.


Examples of Potential Responsibilities: Taking payments, accounting, social media marketing, event planning, bookkeeping, issuing insurance documentation, preparing invoices, updating and verifying client information, scheduling appointments, and maintaining client retention.

Personalities Suited for these Responsibilities: Consistent, Engineer, Knowledgeable, Networker, Persistent, Perfectionist, Planner, Sales Leader, Sales Person

Potential Roles: Recruiter, Receptionist, Administrative Assistant, Office Manager, Operations Manager, Marketing, Billing, Quality Assurance, Executive Assistant.

We’re always here to help! Schedule a call with our service team or send us a chat if you’d like more information on what personality types would be best suited for your unique job offering.

The Power of Inclusive Hiring Practices

In today's diverse world, creating a workplace where everyone feels valued and included isn't just the right thing to do—it's also good for business.  Picture a job where everyone looks and thinks like you. Sounds pretty boring, right? That's where inclusive...

Attract Top Talent with Irresistible Employer Branding!

Let's talk about something that can make-or-break your hiring: employer branding and online presence. So, grab a coffee, pull up a chair, and let's dive into how you can attract top talent with your employer brand. First things first: what makes your company stand out...

Wow Your Applicants: Your Guide to an Exceptional Candidate Experience

Let's talk about something that's often overlooked but oh-so-important: the candidate experience. Picture this: you're on the hunt for a new team member for your insurance agency, franchise, small business, or car dealership. Eventually, you think you found someone...

Unlocking the Power of Social Media in Your Hiring Process

In today's digital age, the landscape of recruitment is continually evolving, and savvy employers are leveraging the power of social media to find and attract top talent. Whether you're a small startup or a large corporation, tapping into the vast network of social...

The Power of a Clean Desk: Boosting Productivity and Efficiency in the Workplace

In the fast-paced and dynamic world of business, the physical workspace is often overlooked in favor of digital tools and virtual collaboration platforms. However, the importance of maintaining a clean and organized desk should not be underestimated. A tidy workspace...

How You May Be Driving Candidates Away: A Guide for Hiring Managers

In today's competitive job market, attracting and retaining top talent is a priority for every organization. However, some hiring managers may unknowingly engage in practices that drive potential candidates away. Creating a positive and inclusive recruitment process...

How To: Create Job Alerts on Indeed

How To Do It: Starting from your Indeed home screen, locate the search bar at the top of your screen. Enter the title of the position you would like to receive job alerts for. Enter the city where you would like to see open positions. After completing those two quick...

So What’s the Deal with Salary Transparency?

Now more than ever it's the candidate who is interviewing us, rather than the other way around. As a result, Salary Transparency laws are being passed quickly around the nation. Why? If a job seeker does not have the salary information for the job posting they are...

Mastering the Art of Job Ads: The Power of Keywords in Attracting Top Talent

Keywords are words or phrases that help us identify the specific requirements of a job. From an employer’s perspective, they pertain to what qualities an employer is looking for in their next potential employee, helping them attract candidates best suited for the role...

Mastering Your Hiring Game in 2024: Tips and Tricks for Strategic Organization

As the dawn of 2024 approaches, it's the perfect time for businesses to reflect on their hiring strategies and set the stage for a successful year ahead. Crafting a well-organized plan can be the key to attracting top talent and achieving your hiring goals. Here are...