...

How to Handle Unqualified Candidates

by | Oct 4, 2023 | Hiring Tips | 0 comments

When you start to review candidates, it is important to understand what “not qualified” means to you, as it means something different to every single agent.

Do they HAVE to be licensed before their start date? Will you turn a candidate away just because they don’t have a degree? Are you willing to train someone if they have the right personality fit, but only have retail sales experience?

In today’s market the competition is high – if you’re looking for someone licensed and experienced, you’re going to have to entice them to leave their current opportunity. It’s all about understanding exactly where you will draw the line, and where you’re willing to offer some extra support to get the right fit into your agency.

Here are some tips for constructing your job ad to ensure you’re attracting the right person for your role:

  • Limit your job Requirements to “must haves,” not “nice to have”
  • Use terms like “bonus points for” or “familiarity with” for skills you would like to see
  • Avoid using industry specific jargon that may not be recognizable to someone without industry experience as it may deter them from applying in the first place
  • Add inclusive benefits like Parental Leave, Child Care, or Paid Family Sick Time – while not every candidate may benefit from these things, mentioning them gives you the opportunity to show your commitment to all employees
  • Job Seekers LOVE to see benefits that help to create a Work/Life Balance
  • Show off their Career Advancement and Training Opportunities or Mentorship
  • Use targeted job ads – no Ninjas or Superstars 😉
  • Limit your Responsibilities to 5-7 bullet pointed tasks – we all know there’s more to it, but we want to give candidates a good idea of the role without overwhelming them
  • Get your ad in front of the right people: use social media and your website to promote that you’re hiring
  • Word of mouth is a great resource as well – referrals lead to some great hires
  • Promote the positive work culture and accomplishments that strengthen your brand

We know hiring can be time consuming, and our assessment is here to help you identify the right fit for the role, but it is important to ensure you are writing your job ad for the candidate you want. Put yourself in their shoes and read the ad before you post it. Do you know exactly what is expected of you? Do you know what you can gain by working in your agency? Make sure the candidate has no questions and that your role is attractive to get the best results.

How to Compete for Top Talent Without Breaking the Bank in 2025

How to Compete for Top Talent Without Breaking the Bank in 2025 The battle to compete for top talent has never been fiercer, and many employers assume they need deep pockets to win. However, the most successful companies understand that attracting top talent isn't...

Producers vs CSRs: Hiring the Right Role at the Right Time

Producers vs CSRs: Hiring the Right Role at the Right Time Insurance agencies face a critical decision when expanding their teams: should they hire producers vs CSRs first? This choice can make or break your agency's growth trajectory. Understanding the distinct...

How Small Businesses Can Win the War for Talent in 2025

How Small Businesses Can Win the War for Talent in 2025 The competition for skilled workers has never been fiercer, and small business hiring faces unique challenges in today's market. While large corporations have big budgets and brand recognition, small businesses...

Staffing for Success: How to Build a High-Performing Insurance Team Before Open Enrollment Season

As autumn leaves begin to fall, insurance companies across the nation face their most crucial period of the year: open enrollment season. This high-stakes window can make or break your annual performance, and success hinges on having the right team in place. Smart...

Sales Floor Reboot: How to Hire Automotive Salespeople Who Actually Convert

The automotive sales industry is facing an unprecedented challenge. Dealerships across the country are struggling to find salespeople who can consistently close deals and build lasting customer relationships. If your sales floor feels more like a revolving door than a...

Avoiding the Summer Slump: Hiring Strategies That Drive Q3 Performance

For many businesses, summer brings sunshine, vacations, and, unfortunately, a hiring slowdown that can stall momentum right when it’s needed most. But the so-called “summer slump” doesn’t have to define your third quarter. With the right strategies, your agency or...

Mid-Year Hiring Check-In: Is Your Team Set Up to Hit Year-End Goals?

As we cross the halfway mark of the year, it’s the perfect time to evaluate your hiring strategy. Is your team built to help you finish the year strong, or is a talent gap holding you back? Whether you're in insurance, automotive, or another growth-focused industry,...

Hybrid Work and Recruitment Strategies: Adapting to 2025 Trends

Hybrid Work Models and Recruitment Strategies: Adapting to 2025 Trends The rise of hybrid work models is reshaping recruitment strategies, offering employers both flexibility and a broader talent pool. As we journey through 2025, organizations that embrace hybrid work...

Improving Employee Retention Through Strategic Onboarding in Auto Dealerships

How Proper Onboarding Reduces Turnover in Automotive Dealerships The automotive industry has long grappled with a significant issue: high employee turnover. In fact, nearly half of the workforce leaves dealerships each year, leading to steep financial losses and...

Mastering Insurance Customer Service: Essential Soft Skills & Best Practices

Mastering Customer Service in Insurance: Essential Soft Skills & Best Practices In the insurance industry, exceptional customer service is key to fostering long-term client relationships and ensuring customer satisfaction. While technical knowledge is essential,...