...

Staying Engaged with Your Candidates

by | May 18, 2022 | Hiring Tips, Interview, Remote | 0 comments

By Eric Waldowski

As the hiring market and landscape change, our hiring processes and ideology needs to change with it. Over the last two years, in particular, following up with applicants and staying engaged has become one of the most simple and least expensive ways to improve your odds of landing your next ideal employee. By looking at your hiring process from the applicant’s point of view, you can provide them with an experience that sets you apart from the other employers. Remember, your job isn’t the only one they’ve applied to and they are comparing you to other employers.

Our team stresses the importance of being competitive, offering appropriate compensation for the role in your market, and looking into flexible work options when it comes to attracting talent. But what about when you do have a competitive ad and receive some candidates? They still have to interview you. When we sit down with a prospective employee, it is truly a two-way street; the candidate is interviewing us just as we are interviewing them. This has never been more true than now in this world of low unemployment and remote work opportunities.

So how do we make the best impression possible on the candidate we want to interview? I will share a few tips that I use to staff our IdealTraits service team.

First, when you get a candidate with the resume and assessment results you are looking for, call them. Emails and texts are great, but I call each candidate that I will interview for a role on our service team as soon as possible after they apply. This personal touch can buy you time with your interview process as the candidate is vetting other offers and can help them imagine themselves in your office. Put yourself in their shoes: you, the owner of the business they applied to work for, called them personally to invite them to an interview. Most companies don’t show this kind of interest, which will help you stand out.

Once the interview is scheduled, I invite a current member of the service team to join. My team is 100% remote, so this takes place via a Zoom meeting. I will host the beginning of the interview with the candidate alone and ask them my questions. Then, I will bring on “their future teammate” and encourage them to ask that teammate questions of their own. A teammate that will speak freely in front of their leader is a sign of great culture to a prospective employee.

Post-interview, I stay continuously engaged, even if I have more folks to interview. It can be a bit more work, but having a bench of warm candidates when making a final decision is a great spot to be in, particularly in the current hiring market. If I spoke to a candidate that’s in the running, I will call them within 2 days of the interview to offer a position or let them know they are in the running. If I need more time to choose, I will email each remaining prospect every 2-to 3 days to let them know we are still interviewing, and always invite them to call me directly with any questions.

Making a few simple changes to your hiring process can increase your odds of getting in front of that right candidate. If you see a resume and think it’s a good fit, others are looking at it too. Act fast and often, to attract your next ideal hire.

Collaborative Hiring: How to Get Your Team Involved Without Slowing Things Down

Collaborative Hiring: How to Get Your Team Involved Without Slowing Things Down The days of HR making hiring decisions in isolation are over. Collaborative hiring has emerged as the gold standard for modern recruitment, with 90% of companies reporting fewer hiring...

Why Small Business Retention Struggles Are Costing You—And The Simple Systems That Fix It

Why Small Business Retention Struggles Are Costing You—And The Simple Systems That Fix It Small business retention challenges can feel overwhelming when you're wearing multiple hats and juggling endless priorities. While large corporations have dedicated HR...

How AI Candidate Screening Transforms Hiring

How AI Candidate Screening Transforms Hiring The recruitment landscape has evolved dramatically, and AI candidate screening is leading the charge. Modern hiring teams are discovering that artificial intelligence doesn't just speed up the process; it fundamentally...

Crisis-Proof Hiring: How Small Businesses Can Staff Smart in an Unpredictable Market

Crisis-Proof Hiring: How Small Businesses Can Staff Smart in an Unpredictable Market Economic uncertainty does not have to derail your small business hiring strategy. In volatile markets, many employers face shrinking candidate pools, rising wage pressure, and longer...

Career Switchers: The Most Valuable Talent Pool in 2026

Career Switchers: The Most Valuable Talent Pool in 2026 The traditional hiring playbook is quickly becoming outdated. While many employers still prioritize candidates with linear career paths, forward-thinking organizations are discovering that career switchers...

Speed-to-Offer vs Pay: Why Hiring Speed Will Dominate 2026 Talent Acquisition

Speed-to-Offer vs Pay: Why Hiring Speed Will Dominate 2026 Talent Acquisition The hiring landscape is undergoing a fundamental shift. While compensation has long been considered the primary lever for attracting talent, speed-to-offer is quickly becoming the defining...

The Reality Check: Why “No One Wants to Work” Isn’t the Whole Story

The Reality Check: Why "No One Wants to Work" Isn't the Whole Story If you've been following hiring discussions lately, you've probably heard the phrase "no one wants to work" more times than you can count. But here's the thing, labor market trends in 2025 tell a...

The First 90 Days: How to Set New Hires Up for Long-Term Success

The First 90 Days: How to Set New Hires Up for Long-Term Success The first 90 days onboarding period is crucial for determining whether a new hire will thrive in your organization or become another turnover statistic. Research shows that employees who experience...

Employee Recognition That Works: Low-Cost Ways to Celebrate Success

Employee Recognition That Works: Low-Cost Ways to Celebrate Success Creating a culture of appreciation doesn't require breaking the bank. In fact, some of the most meaningful employee recognition strategies cost little to nothing while delivering significant returns...

Creating Career Pathways to Boost Retention in 2025

Creating Career Pathways to Boost Retention in 2025 Employee retention has become one of the biggest challenges facing organizations today. While competitive salaries and benefits packages matter, career pathways have emerged as the secret weapon for keeping top...