...

Show Me the Money

by | May 31, 2023 | Hiring Tips | 0 comments

By: Monica Donias

 

Let’s go over why including a salary is important and what it means from a candidate’s perspective.

We’ll start with you – creating your ad. You’ve got your Position, Job Category, and Job Type ready to go. But what should you put in the salary range? We have Help Center Articles to help you out with determining your salary, but let’s talk about why it is so important to include it in your ad.

Filling out the salary section not only allows the candidate to have an expectation as to what they can earn while working for your agency. It also gives you an opportunity to be transparent with them! If you were the candidate looking between the different job opportunities out there, wouldn’t you want to compare salaries from one position to another to pick the best fit?

If you were to go on Indeed.com you can search your job title and zip code to see competitors in your area and the salary ranges they’re offering.

Now putting yourself back in the candidate’s shoes, let’s imagine the experience we have for this role. You may get candidates with different experience levels applying to your job ad and I strongly encourage you to have a breakdown of what a candidate can expect based on their experience level. Someone who has experience, their license, and maybe even some business to bring over, probably won’t make the same amount as an entry-level person.

In your job description or even the benefits section, you can give examples of what candidates can expect to earn based on their experience level. 

For example: “Entry-level candidates can expect to make $40,000 – $60,000 per year in total compensation. Experienced candidates can expect to make $60,000 – $80,000 per year in total compensation, and Top-Level performers can expect to make $80,000 – $100,000 in total compensation.”

You now have given the candidate the opportunity to envision what they can expect to make when they apply. You have also given them the ability to think about their long-term career goals and how with hard work and determination, they can increase their income as they grow their career with you. 

 

Are you stuck trying to figure out what the salary range should be? Here’s an example of a sales role.

The first number in your salary range can be the bare minimum they expect to make within the first year. If you have a base salary plus commission role, I would ask yourself, “What’s the bare minimum amount of policies they need to sell a month to stay on my team?” Then you can multiply the number of policies by how much they would make in commission on average. That number is what they can expect to make in one month so we multiply that by 12 (total months in a year) and that is the bare minimum in commission they can make. We then add that to our base salary and you now have your first number listed! 

For example: “I pay a base salary of $30,000 per year, but if my agents aren’t selling enough policies to make $10,000 per year in commission, I’m going to have to let them go. Therefore, my low-end salary is $40,000.”

We suggest the high end of the range is no more than 1.5x the first number to meet job board criteria. So since we started our range at $40,000, the high end of the range should not exceed $60,000.

 

But wait!! You just said I can talk about how my top performer makes $100,000 a year in my Benefits section, so why can’t my range be $40,000-$100,000? 

I’m so glad you asked. This is where the content of the ad itself provides additional information so that you’re giving candidates a good idea of what they can expect to make their first year with you while demonstrating the amazing growth opportunities your job offers. 

With the goal of trying to attract the best fit for you, key things like Salary Transparency are extremely important. Put yourself in the candidate’s shoes and ask yourself, “What would I look for when comparing opportunities.”

 

If you need any additional resources, be sure to check out our help center for other great topics for improving your hiring strategy.

Staffing for Success: How to Build a High-Performing Insurance Team Before Open Enrollment Season

As autumn leaves begin to fall, insurance companies across the nation face their most crucial period of the year: open enrollment season. This high-stakes window can make or break your annual performance, and success hinges on having the right team in place. Smart...

Sales Floor Reboot: How to Hire Automotive Salespeople Who Actually Convert

The automotive sales industry is facing an unprecedented challenge. Dealerships across the country are struggling to find salespeople who can consistently close deals and build lasting customer relationships. If your sales floor feels more like a revolving door than a...

Avoiding the Summer Slump: Hiring Strategies That Drive Q3 Performance

For many businesses, summer brings sunshine, vacations, and, unfortunately, a hiring slowdown that can stall momentum right when it’s needed most. But the so-called “summer slump” doesn’t have to define your third quarter. With the right strategies, your agency or...

Mid-Year Hiring Check-In: Is Your Team Set Up to Hit Year-End Goals?

As we cross the halfway mark of the year, it’s the perfect time to evaluate your hiring strategy. Is your team built to help you finish the year strong, or is a talent gap holding you back? Whether you're in insurance, automotive, or another growth-focused industry,...

Hybrid Work and Recruitment Strategies: Adapting to 2025 Trends

Hybrid Work Models and Recruitment Strategies: Adapting to 2025 Trends The rise of hybrid work models is reshaping recruitment strategies, offering employers both flexibility and a broader talent pool. As we journey through 2025, organizations that embrace hybrid work...

Improving Employee Retention Through Strategic Onboarding in Auto Dealerships

How Proper Onboarding Reduces Turnover in Automotive Dealerships The automotive industry has long grappled with a significant issue: high employee turnover. In fact, nearly half of the workforce leaves dealerships each year, leading to steep financial losses and...

Mastering Insurance Customer Service: Essential Soft Skills & Best Practices

Mastering Customer Service in Insurance: Essential Soft Skills & Best Practices In the insurance industry, exceptional customer service is key to fostering long-term client relationships and ensuring customer satisfaction. While technical knowledge is essential,...

How to Keep Employees Happy and Boost Business Success in 2025

How to Keep Your Employees Happy and Boost Business Success in 2025 Employee happiness is no longer just a perk—it’s a strategic advantage. Companies with happier employees experience higher engagement, better productivity, and improved retention rates. According to...

How Flexible Work Arrangements Boost Employee Retention and Job Satisfaction

How Flexible Work Arrangements Improve Employee Retention With ongoing staffing shortages and evolving workplace expectations, flexible work arrangements have emerged as a critical strategy for improving employee retention. Studies indicate that employees highly value...

Top In-Demand Jobs and Skills for 2025: Future Workforce Trends

The Future of Jobs in 2025: In-Demand Skills and Workforce Trends The workforce is evolving rapidly, influenced by technological advancements, economic shifts, and demographic trends. The World Economic Forum’s Future of Jobs Report 2025 and Upwork’s In-Demand Skills...