...

Insurance Customer Service Skills: 8 Soft Skills to Hire For and How to Spot Them

by | Feb 19, 2025 | Hiring Tips

Short answer: The insurance customer service skills that matter most are active listening, clear communication, empathy, calm under pressure, dependability, attention to detail, problem-solving and a willingness to learn. These soft skills are much harder to teach a new customer service rep (CSR) than licenses or carrier systems, so hire for them. Check each one before you make an offer, with a validated personality test, the same structured interview questions for every candidate and a short role-play call.

This guide is for insurance agency owners and office managers who hire their own CSRs: what each skill looks like on the job, how to spot it, interview questions and a 10-minute role-play.

Why customer service in insurance runs on soft skills

Customer service in insurance means helping clients through the moments that make or break the relationship: a billing question, a new driver, a renewal that went up, a claim after a storm. Clients usually call when something has gone wrong, so the way a CSR listens and explains matters as much as what they know.

Insurance carriers and related activities employed 12% of all customer service representatives in 2025, second only to retail, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics Occupational Outlook Handbook. The same BLS profile says most CSRs learn the job in 2 to 4 weeks, but those in finance and insurance may need several months of training, and some need a state license.

Those months of training are why soft skills come first. A new CSR's product knowledge grows every week. A CSR who interrupts upset clients, or forgets to call them back, rarely changes.

What soft skills and practical skills do insurance agents and CSRs need?

Insurance CSRs, and the licensed agents who do service work, need two kinds of skills. Practical skills are what the job runs on: a license where your state requires one, carrier and product knowledge, your agency management system and billing. Soft skills are how the person works with clients and your team.

TypeExamples for an insurance CSRCan you train it after the hire?What to do when hiring
Practical skillsA property and casualty or life and health license, carrier portals, your agency management system, certificates, billingYes, with time and a good trainerRequire a license only if you need it on day one. Otherwise plan the training
Soft skillsListening, explaining, empathy, staying calm, follow-through, accuracy, problem-solving, learningSlowly, with a lot of coachingScreen for them before the first interview and check them again in it

Our rule: hire for the soft skills, train the practical ones. The exception is a license. If you need a licensed CSR who can discuss coverage from the first day, that is a hard filter. Licensing rules vary by state, so check with your state insurance department through the NAIC.

Producers are a different hire: they need drive and comfort with persuading people. See our guide to hiring a producer or a CSR at the right time.

The 8 insurance customer service skills to hire for

The list draws on what goes wrong when a CSR is a poor fit and on how the U.S. Department of Labor rates the job. O*NET, the Labor Department's job database, rates dependability (80 out of 100), self-control (79) and cooperation (78) as the work styles with the most impact for customer service representatives, and rates active listening (75) and speaking (72) as the most important skills, according to the O*NET profile for customer service representatives, updated 2026.

Bar chart of O*NET impact ratings for customer service representatives: dependability 80, self-control 79, cooperation 78, social orientation 75, empathy 71, optimism 69, attention to detail 62 and stress tolerance 60.
Work styles with the most impact for customer service representatives, rated 0 to 100. Source: O*NET OnLine, Customer Service Representatives (43-4051.00), updated 2026.

Each skill below has one check you can run outside the interview. The interview questions are in a table further down.

1. Active listening

On the job: Active listening means hearing the whole problem before answering. A client who says "my bill went up" may really be asking whether they can keep the same coverage for less. A good listener catches that.

How to spot it: In the role-play, give a key detail early and see if they use it later.

2. Clear communication, spoken and written

On the job: Clear communication means explaining a deductible, an exclusion or a billing change in plain words, by phone, email or text. "This part of your policy pays for the other driver's car, not yours" saves a call later.

How to spot it: Read their written application answers, and listen to how they explain things in a one-way video interview.

3. Empathy

On the job: Empathy means noticing how the client feels before jumping to the process. After a car accident, a CSR who says "I am sorry, that is a hard day, let's get your claim started" keeps the client's trust, even when the coverage answer is not what they hoped.

How to spot it: In the role-play, see if they acknowledge the feeling before they ask for the policy number.

4. Calm under pressure

On the job: Calm under pressure means staying patient and polite when a client is angry, the phones are ringing and a carrier portal is down. The BLS lists patience as an important quality for CSRs.

How to spot it: A validated personality test shows how a candidate is likely to handle pressure. In the role-play, push back once on their first answer and see if they stay steady.

Want to see how insurance agencies check these skills before the first interview? See IdealTraits for insurance agencies.

5. Dependability

On the job: Dependability means doing what they said they would, every time: the callback by 3 p.m., the endorsement sent before the client's closing. One missed follow-up can cost a client or leave them without coverage.

How to spot it: Watch the small promises during hiring. Did they call back when they said they would? Then check references (step 6 below).

6. Attention to detail

On the job: Attention to detail means getting names, dates, VINs and coverage limits right the first time. A wrong effective date or a missed driver can leave a client uncovered and puts the agency at risk.

How to spot it: Give them a sample certificate request with a planted error, such as the wrong policy number, and ask them to check it.

7. Problem-solving

On the job: Problem-solving means finding the real cause and a way forward instead of passing the client along. Why did the payment fail? Which carrier form fixes this? The BLS lists problem-solving as an important quality for CSRs.

How to spot it: A short cognitive (problem-solving) test before the interview gives you the same check for every applicant.

8. Willingness to learn

On the job: Willingness to learn means picking up new carriers, products and systems without fuss. Rates, forms, portals and state rules change often, and a CSR who resists change slows the whole office down.

How to spot it: In the role-play, add a new rule partway through and see if they use it before the call ends.

Once you have hired a CSR with these skills, our guide to insurance customer service best practices covers training and day-to-day service habits.

How to spot soft skills when hiring a CSR

The best way to spot soft skills is to check each one more than once, the same way for every candidate. A resume shows where someone worked, not whether they listen, stay calm or follow through.

  1. Decide your must-haves. Pick the 3 or 4 skills that matter most in your office, plus any license you need on day one. Our guide on what actually disqualifies a candidate helps you set these.
  2. Give every applicant the same validated personality test. It shows how a candidate is likely to work: steady or fast-paced, detail-focused or big-picture, energized by people or drained by them. Add a cognitive (problem-solving) test, and look at results before you schedule interviews.
  3. Hear them before you meet them. A one-way video interview with 2 or 3 questions shows how a candidate will sound to your clients. See our guide to one-way video interviews.
  4. Run a structured interview. Ask every candidate the same questions (table below) and score each answer from 1 to 5. Structured interviews were the top-ranked selection procedure for predicting job performance in a 2022 review of decades of hiring research by Sackett, Zhang, Berry and Lievens in the Journal of Applied Psychology.
  5. Add the 10-minute role-play call (script below). It is the closest thing to watching them do the job.
  6. Check references. Ask past managers: "Did this person follow through without reminders?" Our guide on how to assess work ethic in job interviews has more ways to check.

Personality results also help you decide where someone fits. One Allstate agency owner who uses IdealTraits put it this way:

"As far as personality, it gives me an insight into how their mind works a little bit, and that would tell me what department they might be best in."

Kristin Maxwell, Allstate agency owner, IdealTraits customer (watch at 20 minutes)

Keep any test fair. The EEOC's guidance on employment tests and selection procedures says tests that screen people out must be job-related, must not be scored differently for different groups, and must come with reasonable accommodations for applicants with disabilities who need them. For why personality matters in hiring, read why personality predicts success better than a resume.

Interview questions for insurance CSR soft skills

Ask every candidate the same question for each must-have skill, and write down what they say before you score it.

SkillQuestion to askA strong answer shows
Active listening"Tell me about a time a customer's real problem was different from what they first said. How did you find out?"They asked questions and repeated the problem back before acting
Clear communication"Explain something complicated you know well, like a phone plan, as if I have never heard of it."Plain words, short steps, a check that you understood
Empathy"Tell me about a time you helped someone who was upset. What did you notice about them?"They name the person's feelings, not only the task
Calm under pressure"Describe your most stressful day at work. What did you do first?"A clear way to sort what comes first, and no blaming
Dependability"How do you keep track of what you promised people when you are busy?"A real system: a task list, reminders, notes in the file
Attention to detail"Tell me about a mistake you caught before it caused a problem."A habit of checking their work, with an example
Problem-solving"Walk me through a problem at work you fixed without being told how."Clear steps from cause to fix
Willingness to learn"What is the last new system or skill you learned, and how?"Steps they took on their own

A role-play call you can run in 10 minutes

A role-play call shows listening, empathy, calm and problem-solving in one go. The candidate does not need insurance knowledge: you are watching how they treat the caller.

  1. Set it up (1 minute). Say: "I will play a client. You are the CSR. If you do not know something, say how you would find out."
  2. Play the call (5 minutes). Example: "My renewal went up and nobody told me why. I have been with you for six years and I am thinking of leaving." Mention early that you just added a teen driver. Halfway through, say you need a signed form back by Friday. Push back once on their first answer.
  3. Debrief (4 minutes). Ask: "What do you think the client really wanted? What would you do after the call?"

Score the role-play from 1 to 5 on five things: did they let you finish, acknowledge how you felt, catch the teen driver, act on the Friday form, and end with a clear next step and a time?

How IdealTraits helps

IdealTraits is an all-in-one hiring platform with AI that helps businesses hire for fit, not just experience. For insurance agencies, that means you can post a CSR job to 100+ job boards, then give every applicant the same validated personality test and cognitive (problem-solving) test before you pick up the phone. IdealTraits assessments were independently validated by Central Michigan University.

AI resume matching gives each applicant a fit score with strengths and gaps. One-way video interviews let you hear and see how a candidate explains things, and AI video interview transcription turns answers into text you can skim. 18,000+ businesses have used IdealTraits to hire. See IdealTraits pre-hire assessments, and for cost questions see IdealTraits pricing.

Insurance customer service skills FAQ

What skills do you need for insurance customer service?

Insurance customer service needs eight soft skills: active listening, clear communication, empathy, calm under pressure, dependability, attention to detail, problem-solving and a willingness to learn. It also needs practical skills that can be trained after the hire, such as carrier and product knowledge, your agency management system and, in many states, an insurance license.

Is insurance customer service a hard job?

Insurance customer service is harder to learn than most CSR jobs. The BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook notes that CSRs in finance and insurance may need several months of training, that some need a state license, and that the work can be stressful when customers are unhappy. That is why calm under pressure and dependability matter so much when you hire.

Caregiver Recruitment for Home Care Franchise Owners: Hire Before Your First Client

Caregiver recruitment for home care franchise owners: who does the hiring, a plan to hire before your first client, checking your state’s caregiver rules, keeping hiring the same across territories, and where to find caregivers.

Texting Job Applicants: How Car Dealerships Automate Every Text (With Templates)

Texting job applicants at a car dealership: the 5 texts to automate, sample wording for each, an interview reminder that cuts no-shows, tweaks for sales, BDC and service, and the consent rules to follow.

How to Hire Plumbers: Find, Check and Keep Licensed Service Plumbers

How to hire plumbers for a service company: which license level the job needs, how to check it, where to find licensed plumbers, a 5-day hiring plan, interview questions, and how to hire apprentice plumbers who stay.

Candidate Screening: How to Screen Job Candidates Before the Interview

Candidate screening in 6 steps for owners and managers who hire without an HR team: must-haves, knockout questions, resumes, a short assessment, a quick call, then the interview. With examples for car sales, caregivers, roofing and accounting firms.

Automotive Technician Test: How to Check a Mechanic’s Skills Before You Hire

An automotive technician test for repair shops and dealership service departments: check certifications, check fit before the visit, then a short written test, a hands-on bay test and a diagnostic talk-through. With sample questions, a bay scorecard and fair test rules.

Why Is Caregiver Turnover So High? 7 Ways Home Care Agencies Reduce It

Caregiver turnover in home care is about 75% a year. Why caregivers leave, how to work out your own turnover rate, and 7 ways home care agencies keep caregivers, from hiring to the first 90 days.

How to Hire a Dealership Finance Manager (F&I) Who Stays

How to hire a dealership finance manager who stays: the traits to look for, a mock menu presentation where the customer says no, the federal rules to ask about and a pay plan with chargebacks in writing.

How to Recruit Home Health Aides and CNAs Fast

How to recruit home health aides and CNAs fast: a one-week hiring plan with the compliance checks built in, the federal rule that lets registered CNAs take aide shifts, and what to screen for.

Restaurant Employee Turnover Rate: 2025 Data and How to Lower Yours

The restaurant employee turnover rate was about 66% in 2025 (BLS). A 5-year table, how to calculate your own rate, and the hiring changes that lower restaurant turnover.

How to Hire Water Mitigation Technicians (and Keep Them Between Storms)

How to hire water mitigation technicians: an honest job ad, fast screening for reliability, a ride-along on a dry-out, hiring fast after a storm, and keeping techs through slow months.